Welcome to the quintessential culinary experience of small-town America, where the charm of nostalgia meets the warmth of community—introducing Coffee Shop. Nestled at 17 Broad St, New Milford, PA 18834, this delightful café has etched itself into the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Here, you won't find bustling Wi-Fi connections vying for your attention; instead, you'll discover the joy of engaging conversations over delicious food that celebrates the rich essence of togetherness.

At Coffee Shop, breakfast and lunch are not just meals; they are cherished rituals. As noted by patrons like Bonnie Gates, the breakfast offerings stand incomparable, featuring homefries that are “to die for” and eggs cooked to perfection. The generous portions ensure no one leaves hungry. Customers rave about the friendly service, often highlighting the sweet disposition of Barb, a passionate staff member deeply invested in making every visit memorable. Victory Curry sums it up perfectly—“there’s a reason why it’s ALWAYS packed.”

While the cozy, country atmosphere invites you to slow down and appreciate your surroundings, the culinary delights beckon. With an array of hearty dishes at reasonable prices, Hank Kaye emphasizes how great the value is for both breakfast and lunch. The exceptional quality of the food, combined with the charm of the diner experience, creates a delightful synergy that keeps patrons coming back.

If you're a fan of comforting eats and authentic connections, Coffee Shop may just become your new go-to spot. Jeremy Blabac captures the essence of this welcoming establishment, stating that “everyone knows everyone else but is also welcoming to any new people.” It’s a place where personal connections thrive, and dining becomes an enjoyable social affair.

So, take a break and step into a simpler time. Jonathan Hall even makes the trip from New York just for the bacon, advocating for its flavorful allure. Each visit promises an experience wrapped in great food, exceptional service, and an atmosphere that makes you feel right at home.

Next time you find yourself in New Milford, don't miss the opportunity to create your own fond memories at Coffee Shop. With every bite and every smile, you’ll understand why this hidden gem deserves a spot on your culinary journey.

For inquiries, feel free to call them at +1 570-465-7292. Your plate awaits!